ADVISORY OPINION NO. 91-EC-007
Issued August 22, 1991
Honorable Tammy Brasuell Gattis
Office of the Prosecutor Coordinator
Tower Building, Suite 750
323 Center Street
Little Rock, AR 72201
Dear Ms. Gattis:
On July 18, 1991, this office received your request for an official opinion, under authority of Initiated Act 1 of 1988 (as amended) and Initiated Act 1 of 1990. Your question, paraphrased, is as follows:
How does the Ethics Commission resolve the apparent conflict in language in ACA § 21-8-403 which states:
"Any person who violates any provision of subchapters 4-8 of this chapter [The Disclosure Act for Lobbyists and State and Local Officials] shall be guilty of a Class A misdemeanor. The culpable mental state required shall be a purposeful violation" (language added)
and the language of A.C.A. § 21-8-702 which states
"Forms used by the persons in filing statements as required in this subchapter (The same act cited above) shall provide for the signature of the person, under penalty of perjury. (A Class C Felony), with respect to the truth and accuracy of the statements made on the form"? (language added).
When is it appropriate to charge a person with a Class A misdemeanor and when is it appropriate to charge a person with perjury?
We believe the option of what criminal statutes to charge a person with or what criminal aspects of civil statute to apply to particular actions of individual's behavior is exclusively within the province of the several duly elected prosecuting attorneys within the state of Arkansas. The determination of whether there is proper application of statutory criminal authority to particular actions, of course, rests within the purview of the courts.
However, we view the following as the standards upon which the Ethics Commission and its staff will proceed when and if such a circumstance arises:
If any person or group of persons (public official, lobbyist, candidate, Political Action Committee) who, having a duty imposed upon them by Act 1 of 1988 or Act 1 of 1990, fails to take the action imposed upon them by law, or if that same person or group of persons have been specifically prohibited from certain acts by the language and intent of the acts but knowingly commits those acts, he, she, or they will be considered to have committed a Class A misdemeanor criminal act.
For example, if a candidate for public office accepts more than one thousand dollars ($1000) from an individual for his campaign, while the law forbids him to do, he or she will be considered to have committed a Class A misdemeanor. The same would apply if a registered lobbyist spent five hundred dollars ($500) lobbying a government agency, but failed to properly register as a lobbyist in Arkansas.
However, any person or group of persons who knowingly attempts to mislead any public official who has the responsibility or authority to enforce the dictates of the ethics and disclosure acts; or who in any other fashion purposefully files false information on forms or statements required to comply with these acts, shall be considered as having committed perjury which is a felony.
We would view any purposeful effort to mislead as very
serious undermining this agency's ability to administer the ethics laws.
We would seek to have such an action prosecuted vigorously.
Jack R. Kearney